Sitemap

How High Can Goodwill Prices Go Before Thrifters Give Up?

Or, have you lost your mind, Goodwill?

4 min readSep 17, 2025

--

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Photo of brightly lit thrift store with furniture and lamps displayed for sale, with people wearing masks while shopping.
Photo by Robinson Greig on Unsplash

I am a dedicated second-hand shopper.

But now? I don’t know if it’s because of inflation, nonprofit organizations needing a lot more money, or resellers desperately snapping up inventory that they hope to sell online, but the prices at my local Goodwill (and other “thrift” stores) are becoming straight-up silly.

My frugal mind is being continually blown

Here is my secret to financial “success” (or “getting by”): I don’t like to shop.

Because I hate going to stores, trying things on, paying retail/non-sale prices, I rarely, rarely go shopping for myself or my family members. Until this year, my teenage children didn’t actually know how to go into a clothing store and try on new clothes.

Instead, I have found a few good annual church rummage sales, quality garage-sale neighborhoods, and a small network of Goodwill and St. Vincent de Paul secondhand stores at which I buy most of our clothes and home goods.

I also wear my clothes until they are worn out. Recently, I went shopping for jeans for the first time in half a decade, and when I came home, I told my spouse, in tones of outrage, “They are charging $8…

--

--

Citizen Reader
Citizen Reader

Written by Citizen Reader

"Money makes people lose their humanity." from Zeke Faux's "Number Go Up: Inside Crypto's Wild Rise and Staggering Fall"

Responses (11)